Beanie Babies Worth Money

Below is a list of Beanie Babies worth money. They feature some of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Generation versions that are hard to find and also rare exclusive Beanie Babies that were not available to the normal public.  eBay is the best marketplace for high and low end Beanie Babies. Very few are worth money, but if you have a 1st Generation Hang Tag Beanie Baby those can sell for over $100.

Condition and the Tags make a huge difference in the price of Beanie Babies. If the toy is well used and shows noticeable wear then that will dramatically impact the final sale price. The Tags play a huge role in determining the value of Beanie Babies. Not only do they identify the toy, but the condition of the tag will also factor into the value.  Beanie Babies with no Hang/Swing Tag will not be worth as much as one that still has the tags attached. Most Beanie Babies have the “Tush Tag” still attached as it was sewn into the toy.

Many of the Beanie Babies listed below are authenticated by 3rd party authenticators. There is a cost associated with grading/authenticating your beanie, usually around $15-20 when shipping is taken into account. If you have a rare beanie, or a 1st generation one, then you might want to consider getting it authenticated to maximize value. There were many fake and counterfeit beanies that were created during the boom of popularity the toys had in the 1990s.

OVER 700 BEANIE BABIES PRICES: 2014 Beanie Babies Price List

Top Selling Beanie Babies Archive:

Pinchers Worth MoneyPunchers AKA Pinchers
Authenticated By: PBBags.com – Korean Tags
Hang Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $1,800.00
Sale Date: June 2, 2013
eBay Seller: tkeeper

Humphrey The Camel
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
No Tags
Final Price: $1,400.00
Sale Date: July 28, 2013
Rare Prototype! Authenticated in 2001

Humphrey the Camels Beanies For Sale

#2 Employee Bear #83/475
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 5th Generation
Tush Tag: 6th Generation
Final Price: $800.00
Sale Date: July 8, 2013

 

 

 
Slither The Snake
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 2nd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $800.00
Sale Date: June 14, 2013
Slither The Snake Beanies For Sale

Coral Casino Bear #/588
Tag Autographed By Ty Warner
Comes with autographed note from Ty
Final Price: $750.00
Sale Date: July 26, 2013

 


Coral Casino Beanie Babies For Sale

Nana
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 3rd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $750.00
Sale Date: July 4, 2013

 

Inky – Tan with No Mouth
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $749.99
Sale Date: June 2, 2013

 

Quacker Worth MoneyQuacker The Duck – Wingless
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 2nd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation – Canada Tags
Final Price: $700.00
Sale Date: March 13, 2013
eBay Seller: tkeeper

 

Peanut the Elephant – Royal Blue
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 3rd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $660.00
Royal Blue Peanut Beanie Babies For Sale

Digger Worth MoneyDigger The Crab – Orange
Authenticated By: Peggy Gallagher
Hang Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation – Canada
Final Price: $650.00
Sale Date: May 23, 2013
eBay Seller: ultrabeaniemasters

Peanut the Elephant – Royal Blue
Hang Tag: 3rd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $649.89
Sale Date: March 28, 2013
eBay Seller: www.bbtoystore.com

 

billionaire 3Billionaire Beanie Baby 3 #390/650
Signed By Ty Warner
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 6th Generation
Tush Tag: 9th Generation
Final Price: $499.89
eBay Seller: www.bbtoystore.com

 

Purple Bean Prototype
Authenticated By: Peggy Gallagher
Prototype Tags
Final Price: $475.00
Sale Date: July 25, 2013
Rare Prototype of an unreleased Beanie Baby!

 

Tangerine Bean Prototype
Authenticated By: Peggy Gallagher
Prototype Tags
Final Price: $450.00
Sale Date: July 27, 2013
Rare Prototype of an unreleased Beanie Baby!

 

Quacker The Duck – Wingless
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 2nd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $410.00
Sale Date: July 8, 2013

 

Billionaire Beanie Baby 1
Signed By Ty Warner
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 5th Generation – Tush Tag: 6th Generation
Final Price: $399.99
Sale Date: July 3, 2013
eBay Seller: tkeeper

 

Humphrey The Camel
Hang Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $395.00
Sale Date: March 30, 2013
eBay Seller: refttt

Billionaire Beanie Baby 12 #141/357
Signed By Ty Warner
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 16th Generation – Tush Tag: 14th Generation
Final Price: $340.00
Sale Date: June 7, 2013
eBay Seller: tkeeper

 

Carvers – With “Boo” on both feet
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 18th Generation
Tush Tag: 13th Generation
Final Price: $250.00
Sale Date: June 25, 2013

 

Web the Spider
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag:2nd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $250.00
Sale Date: August 12, 2013
View Picture

Humphrey The Camel
Hang Tag: 2nd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $195.00
Sale Date: August 16, 2013
30 Bids – Writing on Both Tags
eBay Seller: tkeeper
View Picture

Billionaire Bear #6 #/696
Authenticated By: Peggy Gallagher
Hang Tag: 11th Generation
Tush Tag: 13th Generation
Final Price: $182.50
Sale Date: June 10, 2013
eBay Seller: epicstuffshippedfast

Ally the Alligator
Hang Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $148.11
Sale Date: July 9, 2013
eBay Seller: tkeeper
View Picture

Bronty The Dinosaur
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 3rd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $135.00
Sale Date: August 14, 2013
View Picture

Trap The Mouse
Hang Tag: 3rd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $122.00
Sale Date: August 8, 2013
Notes: 39 bids! Rare!
View Picture

Shampoodle
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 15th Generation
Tush Tag: 13th Generation
Final Price: $81.01
Sale Date: August 19, 2013
Notes: Rare! 2008 Release Was Cancelled by Ty!
View Picture

More Beanie Baby Prices:

 

Free Beanie Babies Price Guide

Categories: Values

211 Comments

  • Jasmyn says:

    Hey hi um I have a Peking panda and well he is Brown because he was in the sun for a few years and his tag is not the greatest but how much do u think he will sell for

  • Tas says:

    Hi I have a number of beanie babies from 1996-1998. Just wondering if its worth me trying to sell them & where to sell them or if I should just keep them to let my daughter play with them. Any advice would be appreciated

  • My Daughter's Daddy says:

    I have bags and bags of these TY babies in the old McDonalds bags numbered everywhere from 1 to 12 with tush tag and hang tag. These were all my sister’s who passed in 2004 but have no use for them and having them just makes me Sad cause shes gone. Would like to know what I can get for them please and can compile a list of what I have if anyone interested?

    • BILLY ROBINSON says:

      sorry about your sister i’m just getting started in collecting beanie babies, but if you cant find any help selling them please let me know i would love to take them off your hands i have no money sorry. just trying to help start some thing to leave my grand kids. if you are interested please let me know. wartyz@myway.com my name is BILLY

  • Anonymous says:

    Hi I have a Patti didn’t know if it was worth anything can any one advise ?

  • Katherine Wilson says:

    I have several hundred beanies in containers. We purchased them all ourselves at stores and have been in the containers since purchase (at least 10-16 years!). Recently going through and we have 10 Valentinos (most w/ the rarest tags) several Princess’s and even a Squealer and Legs. We moved to Australia 8 years ago and they are here. I’d like to find someone that authenticates and sells. I will ship the whole lot to them. Any suggestions??

  • Laura says:

    I have an old beanie baby. Unicorn. Does not have the hear tag but has the old tag by its leg. It’s the old black and white. No name on it. Pvc pellets. 1993. The capital i looks lowercase. Tan horn. Baby blue eyes. Coarse mane. Not in the best shape. But also not in the worst shape. Is she worth anything? I have had her forever. Was my favorite. I have many many many babies. Buddies and minis.

  • Anonymous says:

    I’m just curious I have a glory beanie baby ref stamp is 400 tush tag says 98 and hang tag says 97 could it be worth anything ? Ty

  • JJ says:

    I have a Millennium Beanie Baby that has two tush tags on it, one is the normal one with the TY loop tag on it and the other is a white tag sewn in alon with the normal tag. It has a number on it 2086484 along with information stating that it is made of new materials and not to be removed etc. I know it is not a imposter because I bought it from the gift shop I worked in and I ordered and received the babies directly from the TY company myself. I have not seen any others with the two tags, is this something special? Does it make it worth more?

    • Love My Beanies says:

      Does it look like this one:

      If so, it’s an added Canadian tush tag. It probably adds a few dollars to the price of a normal Millennium Beanie Babies.

  • Angie says:

    I am just wondering the worth if any, of the American trio …. Righty, Lefty, and Libearty! All in their packages…. Or maybe you can tell me where to find the worth of other beanies! Thanks so much!

    • Love My Beanies says:

      Hello, the American Trio set typically sells online for between $5-10. eBay tends to be the most active marketplace for Beanie Babies.

  • melina terry says:

    I have “The Attic Treasures Collection” Orion Ty Beanie Baby in great condition with a pink hang tag instead of a red one. Some I have seen online with a pink hang tag are worth $200,000 but I can’t find anything about the one I have. Surely I don’t have the only Orion with a pink tag! If anyone knows how much it is worth or how i can find out please let me know! Thanks!

    • holly says:

      Hi there, I can get my hands on punches the lobster 1st Gen tag and tush tag…..2 are for sale the only difference is the tush tag , one has 4 line Korean and the other has 5 line Korean? I need to move fast and info would be great….also one of the hang tags has the glue on it from the price sticker being removed. ….you can read most of it….

      • Love My Beanies says:

        If they aren’t authenticated by someone like Peggy G or True Blue Beans I wouldn’t buy them unless they are basically free.

        • holly says:

          Thank you!

        • melina terry says:

          Is the Attic Treasure Collection with the pink hang tag worth anything?

          • Love My Beanies says:

            A few of the very early ones have some value, similar to how Beanie Babies work, the earlier they were made the better.

          • melina terry says:

            Ok thank you. I have several made in 1993. Not sure when all of this started so I don’t know if it will be considered an early one..

          • Love My Beanies says:

            The dates on the tags don’t mean much. A 1st Gen with 1993 or 1995 won’t effect the value. It’s the combination of Tush and Hang tag that makes it valuable. Ones with a 1st Generation Tush Tag AND 1st Gen Hang Tags are worth the most.

            Generally speaking:
            1st Hang Tag + 1st Gen Tush Tag- big value
            2nd Hang Tag + 1st Gen Tush Tag – have solid value
            3rd Hang Tag + 1st Gen Tush Tag – Some value

            Anything else without a 1st Gen Tush Tag, pretty much in the $5 range except for a few of them.

          • melina terry says:

            Ok I see. Thank you so much for your time and information.

  • JackieSmithAuthor says:

    Hi! I have an Osito red Mexican Flag Bear, pretty much in mint condition, who came with two hanging tags, one on each ear. Would this be considered a rare Beanie Baby? Thank you so much!

    • Love My Beanies says:

      There are examples of Beanies that have two hang tags. It doesn’t effect the value that much because it would be easy to apply another hang tag to any Beanie. Beanie Babies with two tush tags would be an interesting item.

  • Chris says:

    We have a whole bunch too! Just recently learned about the oddities that can add value so we went exploring in our lot. Guess what! We found that we have ones with the double I in original, no r in surface, pink stamps, and double reds ( to hold swing tags)! We also have a ton of originals regular size and just about all of the teenie ones too! Any suggestions on how to advertise to the most interested audiences? We have a daughter trying to get through college, even textbook money would help. Thanks! http://newyork.craigslist.org/wch/clt/4750948569.html

  • Debbie says:

    I have a very rare 1996 “peace” bear with the two errors and no number on inside of tush tag also very rare PVC pellets and not PE Pellets in mint condition. what is the value?

  • Debbie says:

    Hi I just found a “peace bear” with the two errors and no number on the tush tag plus PVC pellets. is it as rare as I see online and what is the value thanks

  • stormy says:

    I have a Bessie with pvc pellets. On the tush tag, where it has the TY heart logo, there’s a sticker the logo. Idk what is underneath, not wanting to ruin it by peeling the sticker off.

    • Anonymous says:

      If the sticker on the back of the tag has “surface wash” on it it’s covering a miss spelling. May be worth some money

  • rslshas one says:

    Wondering if someone can tell me a little about a jellyfish that is yellowish and pinkish has no hanging tag just tag of ty sewed and has odd stamp on tag please help my wife and i out. We have a couple of these ty beanie babies thanks

  • JOsh says:

    Now I am just curious, I have a Platinum Membership kit Clubby II bear with a gold coin, I have the whole kit. I am just curious if this is worth anything

  • stormy says:

    I….have a purple Peanut….at least the hang and tush both says its peanut…never heard of a purple Peanut….what do i do with it?

  • Stormy bledsoe says:

    I have a 1999 signature bear with a dark red and gold ribbon, rather than a brown and gold ribbon. Worth anything?

  • josh says:

    I have several Beanie babies I need to get rid of. Some very nice ones. I’ll get rid of them for an amazing deal.. I just want them out of the hose please let me know if anyone is interested

  • casey says:

    I have Princess, Handmade in Indonesia 1997, In mint shape everything matches, whats it worth

  • Whitley says:

    I have Millenniumthe bear and Spangle the bear. Are they worth anything?

  • stephanie says:

    Hello, I have a plush bunny that I think is called nibbles. They made a brown one and a white one. I have the brown. the tush tag has only the red heart with ty in it and the other side just says ty, Inc 1993 and then pvc china. (more words in between) I do not have the hang tag. I have looked and noticed that the tush tag was 2nd generation. Is it worth anything?

  • Cheryl says:

    I have 6 beanie babies most have both tags not the original one with the heart, I have the book one but the tags on the babies are dated from 1996 to 2002

Comment on Beanie Babies!