,

Beanie Babies Worth Money

Below is a list of Beanie Babies worth money. They feature some of the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Generation versions that are hard to find and also rare exclusive Beanie Babies that were not available to the normal public.

eBay is the best marketplace for high and low end Beanie Babies.

Very few Beanie Babies are worth money, but if you have a 1st Generation Hang/Tush Tag version those can sell for over $100.

Sell Your Beanie Babies

Highest Priced Beanie Babies – May 2017

Condition and the Tags make a huge difference in the price of Beanie Babies. If the toy is well used and shows noticeable wear then that will dramatically impact the final sale price.




The Tags play a major role in determining the value of Beanie Babies. Not only do they identify the toy, but the condition of the tag will also factor into the value.

Beanie Babies with no Hang/Swing Tag will not be worth as much as one that still has the tags attached.

Many of the Beanie Babies listed below are authenticated by 3rd party authentication services.

There is a cost associated with grading/authenticating your beanie, usually around $15-20 when shipping is taken into account. If you have a rare beanie, or a 1st generation one, then you might want to consider getting it authenticated to maximize value.

There were many fake and counterfeit beanies that were created during the boom of popularity the toys had in the 1990s.

What Are Your Beanie Babies Worth?

#1 Bear
Authenticated by True Blue Beans
Serial Numbered #159/253
Autographed by Ty Warner
Sold For: $5,600
Date Sold: April 27, 2017
Oddity: No #1 Emblem

Blackie
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Tags: 1st Generation
Final Price: $2,999.99
Sale Date: April 17, 2016

Authenticated Blackie Price Guide

Billionaire Bear #6
Rare Prototype!
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Tags: Advent
Final Price: $2,026
Sale Date: May 2, 2017

Punchers AKA Pinchers
Authenticated By: PBBags.com – Korean Tags
Tags: 1st Generation
Final Price: $1,800.00
Sale Date: June 2, 2013

eBay Seller: tkeeper

#1 Bear
Authenticated by Peggy Gallagher
Serial Numbered #108/253
Autographed by Ty Warner
Sold For: $1,500.00
Date Sold: September 26, 2014

Humphrey The Camel
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
No Tags
Final Price: $1,400.00
Sale Date: July 28, 2013
Rare Prototype! Authenticated in 2001

Humphrey the Camels Beanies For Sale

Teddy – Old Face Cranberry
Authenticated by: True Blue Beans
Heart Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Sold For: $1,300.00
Date Sold: July 1, 2014

#2 Employee Bear #83/475
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 5th Generation
Tush Tag: 6th Generation
Final Price: $800.00
Sale Date: July 8, 2013

Slither The Snake
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 2nd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $800.00
Sale Date: June 14, 2013

Slither The Snake Beanies For Sale

Coral Casino Bear #/588
Tag Autographed By Ty Warner
Comes with autographed note from Ty
Final Price: $750.00
Sale Date: July 26, 2013

Coral Casino Beanie Babies For Sale

Nana
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 3rd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $750.00
Sale Date: July 4, 2013

Inky – Tan with No Mouth
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $749.99
Sale Date: June 2, 2013

Quacker The Duck – Wingless
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 2nd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation – Canada Tags
Final Price: $700.00
Sale Date: March 13, 2013

eBay Seller: tkeeper

Peanut the Elephant – Royal Blue
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 3rd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $660.00

Royal Blue Peanut Beanie Babies For Sale

Digger The Crab – Orange
Authenticated By: Peggy Gallagher
Hang Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation – Canada
Final Price: $650.00
Sale Date: May 23, 2013

eBay Seller: ultrabeaniemasters

Peanut the Elephant – Royal Blue
Hang Tag: 3rd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $649.89
Sale Date: March 28, 2013

eBay Seller: www.bbtoystore.com

Billionaire Beanie Baby 3 #390/650
Signed By Ty Warner
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 6th Generation
Tush Tag: 9th Generation
Final Price: $499.89

eBay Seller: www.bbtoystore.com

Purple Bean Prototype
Authenticated By: Peggy Gallagher
Prototype Tags
Final Price: $475.00
Sale Date: July 25, 2013
Rare Prototype of an unreleased Beanie Baby!

Tangerine Bean Prototype
Authenticated By: Peggy Gallagher
Prototype Tags
Final Price: $450.00
Sale Date: July 27, 2013
Rare Prototype of an unreleased Beanie Baby!

Quacker The Duck – Wingless
Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 2nd Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $410.00
Sale Date: July 8, 2013

Billionaire Beanie Baby 1
Signed By Ty Warner
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 5th Generation
Tush Tag: 6th Generation
Final Price: $399.99
Sale Date: July 3, 2013

eBay Seller: tkeeper

Humphrey The Camel
Hang Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Final Price: $395.00
Sale Date: March 30, 2013

eBay Seller: refttt

Billionaire Beanie Baby 12 #141/357
Signed By Ty Warner
Authenticated By: PBBags.com
Hang Tag: 16th Generation
Tush Tag: 14th Generation
Final Price: $340.00
Sale Date: June 7, 2013

eBay Seller: tkeeper

Carvers – With “Boo” on both feet

Authenticated By: True Blue Beans
Hang Tag: 18th Generation
Tush Tag: 13th Generation
Final Price: $250.00
Sale Date: June 25, 2013

Related Posts

Patti Beanie Babies Price Guide

Snort Beanie Babies Price Guide

Humphrey Beanie Babies Price Guide

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Nena Livingston - 21 July, 2017

I have lots of beanie babies with covers on all the tags. I also have lots of the ones sold at McDonald’s, still in the original packaging. Email me if interested.

Reply
Misty Rudd - 20 July, 2017

I have a lot of beanie babies to sell if interested email me at misty2rudd@gmail.com serious inquiry only

Reply
Nina - 18 July, 2017

I have some original beanies and ready to sell.. ninakailani@gmail.com

Reply
Rhonda - 14 July, 2017

I have a mystic beanie baby with a brown horn and thicker hair, how much do you think I can sell her for? She has all her tags and is never been played with!!

Reply
Marrissa stetler - 10 July, 2017

I have over 37 tys and most of them are rare and I am starting a huge collection anybody want to sell theirs?? If so reply please thanks.

Reply
    Danika - 10 July, 2017

    I have the princess, Halo, Peace, Millennium and several others if you are interested in buying.

    Reply
    Pamela Phillips - 13 July, 2017

    I have lots of them all for sale phillipspam49@gmail.com

    Reply
    Andrew - 13 July, 2017

    If you’re still interested in getting some more, I have found a ton after going through storage.

    Reply
    Anonymous - 15 July, 2017

    I have 2 boxes full oe Tys also have the set of mcdonald beanies if interested text 9032587700

    Reply
    Melisa - 15 July, 2017

    I have several restored beanies. Might have something you’re interested in.

    Reply
    Sonja - 18 July, 2017

    Selling “rainbow” a Chameleon and “Kicks” a green soccer bear. Both have Tag Errors. Mint condition.

    Reply
    donna simmons - 19 July, 2017

    Hi Marisa, I have many first addition beanies, with tags. what are you looking for? Donna

    Reply
    Brandon - 20 July, 2017

    We have several beanie babies if you are interested

    Reply
    Joshua - 21 July, 2017

    I have hope ,two fuzz’s, valentino,cashew,signature usa teddy, seymore the seal and more and all in mmint condition i would be willing to send you those mentioned plus more for the one time never again price 900.00 you can contact me at hrdlikekoncrete@gmail.com

    Reply
Karen Mueller - 9 July, 2017

I have about 300 plus beanies to sell..all of them in excellent condition with plastic protectors on the tags. Please email me if interested..some of them are valued higher than original. I have the Spangles, red white and blue faces, all the birthday beanies, and several others that are quite old. Please contact me if interested.

Reply
Toni - 2 July, 2017

I have a beanie baby called Cawley, it’s a crow dressed in blue jeans with a hat. Appears to have a 1st generation tag. Tush tag says
“Handmade in China
1993 TY INC
Surface Washable
All New Material
Polyester Fiber & P.V.C. Pellets
Reg.No. PA 1965
CE

Reply
Lisa - 1 July, 2017

I have some rare beanie babies I’m looking to sell. PleAse get back at

Reply
Priscilla favors - 29 June, 2017

Where can i get beanie baby baby book

Reply
Juliza - 26 June, 2017

This is helpful

Reply
Maureen - 26 June, 2017

I have some rare beanie babies can anyone guide me in the right direction to sale them.

Reply
NANCY - 25 June, 2017

I HAVE A FEW BAGS OF BEANIE BABIES BUT WAS WONDERING WHERE I COULD GET THE PLASTIC CONTAINERS TO PUT THEM IN TO KEEP THEM FROM GETTING RUINED ….. THANK YOU IN ADVANCE

Reply
tara - 22 June, 2017

I have recently found my love for beanie babies so i do whatever i can to find them..i dont know a lot but i do know they must have the tags on..im looking to sell what i have so i can move and i want them to go to someone who will love them like me

Reply
Monique - 19 June, 2017

Good Day…Upon the passing of my mother, I finally decided to go through her closet and I found a box full of authenticated, Beanie Babies dated back to 1993 and 2 Millennium babies. I would like to sell them at a far price. One in its original case. All tags are there and are in mint condition. Please feel free to contact me through email. Thank you for your time and consideration

Reply
Carol - 16 June, 2017

Hello There, was looking at my beanie babies and found a couple of them was on the valuable list found on my facebook page. I have a princess Diana bear and a Millennium bear. Also found a small Teenie Beanie Babies, Claude the Crab. Not sure how to see the value of my pieces. Let me know. Excited to know more.

Reply
Nancy - 15 June, 2017

How do you get them authenticated? I have a tote full… Thanks, N

Reply
Angie Szush - 15 June, 2017

Where is the best place to price and sell not 1st generation beanie babies?

Reply
J. A. Garoutte - 13 June, 2017

I have over 1,600 beanie babies from the 90’s.

I also have 64 1999 Internation bears and 3 McDonald display cases. I also have over 925 Teenie beanie babies – all complete sets.

Everything listed above I have lists of and all are in original bags or boxes. All have covers on the tags and are brand new.

I’m trying to sell all together as I don’t have the time to sell item by item. Any thoughts. Thank you, J.A. Garoutte 209-942-2100

Reply
    Jacob - 20 June, 2017

    Do you have a facebook contact I can get a hold of you if still available?

    Reply
Brookley - 6 June, 2017

My binnie babby has an old face but no tag it is Earin and i was wondring if you can help

Reply
Patricia Barry - 5 June, 2017

Where’s a good place to sell them. I have hundreds of original mint. I just wanna get rid of them.

Reply
Katie - 29 May, 2017

I have a Mystic with a tush tag that says 1993 the horn has red line swirled around it, the red TY tag is gone, but the red punch through that holds the TY tag is still there.. Is the unicorn still worth money?

Reply
Leave a Reply: