,

Mystic Beanie Babies Price Guide

Seller received positive feedback

Fine Mane

Mystic

Hang Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Tush Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Authenticated By: True Blue Beans

Sold For: $1,050

Date Sold: March 2017


Hang Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Tush Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Authenticated By: True Blue Beans

Sold For: $943

Date Sold: March 2017

Fine Mane

Canadian Tush Tag


Hang Tag Generation: 3rd Generation

Tush Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Authenticated By: True Blue Beans

Sold For: $40

Date Sold: March 2017

Fine Mane


Brown Horn Version

Yellow Star on Hang Tag

Very Common – Not Rare

Value: $5 +/-


Iridescent Horn Version

Yellow Star on Hang Tag

Very Common – Not Rare

Value: $5 +/-

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Joyce Miller - 24 July, 2017

I have a Beanie Buddy called Humphrey the Camel. He is very rare, retired, &, according to Ty, not many were made. Before Ty closed down their listing where they gave let you know what the older, rare ones were worth, they gave me a estimate of $1600.00. I was going to put him on e-bay but haven’t had a chance. Can any one give me an estimate of what Humphrey might sell for?

Reply
Anonymous - 23 June, 2017

What’s the difference with the ear tags that have style numbers on them? Worth more or less?

Reply
Phyllis - 22 June, 2017

I have a Spinner with a Snort tag. Can’t find any info. Any ideas?

Reply
Candy Page - 20 June, 2017

I have a Red Digger with an Inky tag. What is it worth?

Reply
Annalisa - 19 June, 2017

I have a Mystic with an iridescent horn, but mine has the yarn mane/tail. Is it the same value as the one shown above that has the fine mane/tail?

Reply
    Love My Beanies - 19 June, 2017

    Iridescent horn versions are very common and have little to no value.

    Reply
      Karen Cross - 13 July, 2017

      Actually thats not true about the Mystic with iridescent horn and yellow star on tag. They actually go for 1000 to 4000 depending on what year the ty is. Did research online to check and see if what you have said is correct and it is not correct.

      Reply
        Love My Beanies - 13 July, 2017

        NO THEY DO NOT. The iridescent horn versions start at 4th Generation. You can find them all day for under $10. All day. Please post where you are finding this “research”. You are probably looking at Bonanza or eBay listings that have not sold.

        Reply
Leave a Reply: