2

June

Mystic Beanie Babies Price Guide

Seller received positive feedback

Fine Mane

Mystic

Hang Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Tush Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Authenticated By: True Blue Beans

Sold For: $1,050

Date Sold: March 2017


Hang Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Tush Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Authenticated By: True Blue Beans

Sold For: $943

Date Sold: March 2017

Fine Mane

Canadian Tush Tag


Hang Tag Generation: 3rd Generation

Tush Tag Generation: 1st Generation

Authenticated By: True Blue Beans

Sold For: $40

Date Sold: March 2017

Fine Mane


Brown Horn Version

Yellow Star on Hang Tag

Very Common – Not Rare

Value: $5 +/-


Iridescent Horn Version

Yellow Star on Hang Tag

Very Common – Not Rare

Value: $5 +/-

About the author 

Love My Beanies

  • I have a Mystic with an iridescent horn, but mine has the yarn mane/tail. Is it the same value as the one shown above that has the fine mane/tail?

      • Actually thats not true about the Mystic with iridescent horn and yellow star on tag. They actually go for 1000 to 4000 depending on what year the ty is. Did research online to check and see if what you have said is correct and it is not correct.

        • NO THEY DO NOT. The iridescent horn versions start at 4th Generation. You can find them all day for under $10. All day. Please post where you are finding this “research”. You are probably looking at Bonanza or eBay listings that have not sold.

  • I have a Beanie Buddy called Humphrey the Camel. He is very rare, retired, &, according to Ty, not many were made. Before Ty closed down their listing where they gave let you know what the older, rare ones were worth, they gave me a estimate of $1600.00. I was going to put him on e-bay but haven’t had a chance. Can any one give me an estimate of what Humphrey might sell for?

  • I have a fine mane Mystic with brown horn, 1st generation tush tag and 2nd generation hang tag (slightly creased). Do you have any idea if it has any value? Thank you!!

  • I have a Mystic with a brown horn and yarn mane and tail. It has the second generation swing tag with “Mysfic” printed inside. Also, it has a black and white tush tag. Is this valuable?

  • I have a Mystic with an iridescent horn and course yarn white mane. Also the swing tag (1994) and rush tag (1993) are different dates. Do you have an idea what this may run for in mint condition?

  • My Mystic is dated 1993 and has an iridescent horn with a yarn mane and tail. So I see you said iridescent isn’t worth anything but I also see where you said they weren’t produced until the 4th generation…mine is not 4th generation. Worth anything?

  • Does an iridescent horn version with a white star hang tag have much value over $10?

    I also have a Ringo with the same white star hang tag.

  • I have a fairly extensive collection of beanies that I bought for my daughter starting 25 years ago. I would like to sell the whole collection and put the money in my grandson’s college fund. I know I need to compile a list them all first, but then what is the best way to go about it? Thanks for your help.

  • I have a Mystic Ty and it has an iridescent horn with a white yarn mane. She has no errors on her tags. Do have an idea of what this is worth?

  • Help, Mystic beanie with errors on swing tag and Daisy tush tag. Brown horn, yarn mane and tail. I can’t find any info on this error, is it very rare?

  • I have a mystic on which I’ve found little information online. The tag says “Mysfic style 4007” – Can you give me information regarding it?

  • I have mystic unicorn small tah says 1993. Yarn hair. Red hang tag has yellow star but encased cant see the date. So anything with yellow star not first generation, correct?

  • what about Mystic style 4007 w/Nurnberg tag. Also star is missing on tush tag & it says P.V.C pellets. Also hang tag says 1994 tush tag 1993 I read somewhere that they are made that way but most of mine have matching dates on ea tag.

    I also have coarse mane iridescent horn but she is missing hang tag :{

  • I have a rainbow tail mystic with 1994 birth date, and a yarn tail mystic with 1994 birth date, both in mint condition with hang tags and tush tags I’m interested in selling

  • I have a mystic rainbow tail birth date 1994, and a mystic yarn tail birth date 1994 . Both are in mint condition.

  • I have a Mystic that has yarn mane and tail. Iridescent horn. Red hang tag with yellow star. Red hang tag says 1994 but the tag on leg says 1993. Trying to get an estimate on the value.

  • hi, i have mystic with a brown horn, and the wrong tag, the tag that is on there is for jolly the walrus. how much do you think it would be worth. i do have a jolly the walrus, and he has the right tag on it.

  • I have mystic with a brown horn and coarse yarn mane with the wrong tush tag, the tag that is on there is for jolly the walrus. How much do you think it’s worth?

  • I have a 1st generation mystic unicorn with nose errors. Not mint but good condition. 9wrinkle on tag) what would it’s value be plz?

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

    Popular Posts

    >