⚠️ Reality Check: Most Ally NOT Valuable
Very few Ally the Alligator Beanie Babies are worth money. Many Ally Beanie Babies were made over many years and very few will have the 1st gen tags.
Some of the 4th and 5th generation Ally Beanie Babies can be found for less than $5.
🐊 Ally The Alligator
March 14, 1994
October 1, 1997
4032
1, 2, 3, 4
1, 2, 3, 4, 5
💰 What Makes Ally Valuable?
Now if you have a 1st generation Ally, then you might be able to get over $100 for it. It just all depends on current market conditions and it might be wise to get it authenticated to maximize your value.
Ally’s with a 2nd generation hang tag and a 1st generation tush tag can still bring in some money, but typically less than $100.
🔍 Check Your Tags
Tag generations dramatically impact the value. Use these guides to identify your Ally:
💵 Actual Ally Sales (2013)
🐊 1st Gen Hang + 1st Gen Tush – $148.11
1st Generation
1st Generation
July 9, 2013
tkeeper
🐊 2nd Gen Hang + 1st Gen Tush – $50.00
2nd Generation
1st Generation
August 6, 2013
jaskor33
Note: “To” and “From” was written on inside of tag, which can impact value. Seller had only 1 feedback at time of transaction.
🐊 2nd Gen Hang + 1st Gen Tush – $38.00
2nd Generation
1st Generation
May 26, 2013
nebbygal
Note: Seller said they were the original owner. Hang tag had a slight rip on the back side, probably from peeling off a price label.
🐊 2nd Gen Hang + 1st Gen Tush (Damaged) – $13.40
2nd Generation
1st Generation
June 30, 2013
tkeeper
Note: The hang tag was well mangled, which greatly impacted the price. Looked like it went through the washing machine. A little rip here and there won’t impact price that much, but this tag was badly damaged.
🐊 3rd Gen Hang + 2nd Gen Tush – $8.99
3rd Generation
2nd Generation
May 19, 2013
everything_u_need_and_more
Note: If your Ally doesn’t have a 1st gen or 2nd gen hang tag, this is the kind of price you’ll get… but usually less.
i have an ally alligator beanie baby made in idonesia how does that effect its value
I HAVE 3 ALLY DOB 3/14/94 #4032 PERFECT CONDITION
I have an Sly the Aligator, was made in China style # 4032 perfect condition, born on 3-14′-94. What is it’s value in excellent condition? Thank you
Sherry Williamson
My mother in law collected these . She past away last Oct. I have been getting ready for a garage sale. I went to storage and found so many of these. Still in the happy meal bags and 1st generation all of them. The storage was climate controlled. So they are in awesome shape Was wondering best place to sell them. Thank you Sherry.
I have Ally the Alligator, 4/4, PVC, China #4032. It came with a necklace around the neck. Read plastic heart with Name and birthday in the center. My other Ally’s do not have this. Can someone tell me is this is different for some reason. she is in near mint condition at least. Thank you so much.