Beanie Babies Price Guide – Letter I

This is a Beanie Babies price guide for ones beginning with the letter I. There aren’t that many Beanie Babies that begin with I, if you have one that isn’t listed on this page, leave me a comment and I will add it to the list.

Key Beanie Babies on this page are Inky the Octopus. 1st Generation versions with no mouth are very rare and almost impossible to find. They can easily sell for over $300 in decent condition. While worth less, Inch the Worm with 3rd/1st Generation Tags are still a very nice find.

Beanie Babies on This Page Worth Money


inky 2Inky – Without a Mouth
Swing Tag: 1st Generation
Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Sold For: $450.00
Date: March 15, 2014
Top Beanie Babies Sales – March 2014


The QTY Sold is the total number of Beanie Babies that were used to get the average price.

Beanie Name Style Number Average Price QTY Sold
Icebox The Polar Bear 40790 $3.25 5
Icecubes 48420 $5.06 10
Icepack 44205 $3.24 6
Icing 40241 $4.40 2
Iggy 4038 $3.82 31
Illinois (I Love) 40127 $4.66 3
Illinois Violet 40293 $2.51 6
Inch (3rd/1st Tags) 4044 $22.84 3
Inch (4th Gen or Later Tags) 4044 $2.89 18
Independence (Blue) 40366 $2.59 5
Independence (Red) 40366 $3.28 4
Independence (White) 40366 $3.13 6
India 4291 $4.55 29
Inky (Grey No Mouth) 1st/1st Tags 4028 $381.00 2
Inky (Grey No Mouth) 2nd/1st Tags 4028 $122.50 2
Inky (Grey w/ Mouth) 3rd/1st Tags Authenticated 4028 $58.77 1
Ireland (I Love) 46019 $9.63 8
It’s A Boy 40056 $5.20 1
It’s A Girl 40055 $2.85 2


#1-4H Letter I
Letter R
Letter A
Letter J
Letter S
Letter B
Letter K
Letter T
Letter C
Letter L
Letter U
Letter D
Letter M
Letter V
Letter E
Letter N
Letter W
Letter F
Letter O
Letter X
Letter G
Letter P
Letter Y
Letter H
Letter Q
Letter Z

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

ANN RENTFRO - 26 August, 2016

I have a pink inky with no mouth with errors in the tags. Hang tag says 1994 and tush tag is 1993. It is PVC also. Is this valuable? I only see the tan ones without a mouth. Thanks!

    Love My Beanies - 26 August, 2016

    The years on the tags are not errors, that is how they were originally made. The no mouth on a later version Inky probably won’t have much value unless authenticated.

symphony007 - 18 August, 2016

Inky, pink, with mouth

michelle - 21 March, 2016

how much would a tan inky first generation without mouth be worth without the ty heart tag. Has other tag stating 1993. Very good condition still.

Kali - 20 March, 2016

I have an I love you forever set of two February 19, 2005 beanie. What is the price? Has one swing tag and two tush tags. Excellent condition

Larissa - 14 January, 2016

I have a pink inky style 4028 with mouth with both tags attached

Maria - 9 January, 2016

I have a 1st Generation pink Inky and wonder what the value of it is.

    Love My Beanies - 14 January, 2016

    It would depend if it had both tags and what kind of shape it was in.

katrina boetto - 10 September, 2015

I have an “in memory of John F Kennedy Jr patriotic plush, do you know anything about them? still in plastic has name and dates on the back with a flag attached to his hand what would it be worth, ive searched the internet and cant find one anywhere..

Anonymous - 13 August, 2015

I have an iggy that the tag by its tail says stretch. Does this mistake make it more valuable?

    Love My Beanies - 13 August, 2015

    Error tags are quite common and do not impact the value.

Anonymous - 24 July, 2015

I have Luchy ladybug, Issy igunana. Are they of any value?

Jon - 14 July, 2015

I have a bear named Issy. What is he worth?

Elsie - 21 April, 2015

I have collection of beanie babies 1997 to 2001 how can I find prices please

Anonymous - 28 December, 2014

I have no idea if my Inch is a 1st gen,3rd,4th,or other.

Tom Stewart - 16 September, 2014

I have a baby labeled ISSY named after Isadore Sharp, Founder and Chairman of the Four Seasons Hotel and resorts. Do you have a value for this baby? Thank you.

    Love My Beanies - 18 September, 2014

    Hello! They tend to sell online for about $3.00.

Adrean - 7 June, 2014

I have a inky. But its pink has pvc pellets and the the I in beanie is l ? Is it worth anything its in great condition.

Leave a Reply: