,

Beanie Babies Price Guide – Letter M

Beanie Babies price guide for ones that begin with letter M.  Prices are from completed auctions on eBay.

mysticMystic the Unicorn
Hang Tag: 1st Generation – Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Sold For: $299.99
Date Sold: January 1, 2014
Top Beanie Babies Sales – January 2014




 

Beanie Baby Hang Tag Gen Tush Tag Gen Price
M.C. The Bear Beanie VI 14 13 $3.05
M.C. The Bear II Mastercard 10 11 $3.26
Mac The Cardinal 5 7 $3.29
Magenta The Dog Blue’s Clues 14 13 $11.99
Magic The Dragon 3 1 $19.89
Magic The Dragon 4 3 $3.00
Mandy The Panda Bear 11 13 $3.01
Manny The Manatee None 2 $9.89
Mardi Gras The Bear 13 13 $3.01
Marsh The Frog 15 13 $3.49
Marshall The Horse 12 13 $2.79
Marshall The Horse 12 13 $3.01
Mascotte The Bear 14 13 $3.01
Masque The Bear 13 13 $2.25
Masque The Bear 13 13 $10.26
Mastercard The Bear V 5 13 13 $2.75
Mattie The Cat 10 11 $3.30
Mel The Koala 4 3 $1.44
Merlin The Cat 19 15 $4.95
Millenium 5 7 $2.02
Minksy The Bunny 13 13 $3.50
Minneapolis The Bear 12 13 $0.99
Mississippi The Bear I Love 13 13 $2.14
Missy The Monkey 18 14 $6.89
Mistletoe 7 10 $2.50
Mooch The Monkey 5 7 $2.09
Moonlight The Cat 13 13 $3.49
Moosletoe The Moose 12 13 $1.00
Muddy The Dog 11 13 $3.05
Muddy The Dog 11 13 $4.80
Muff The Cat 13 13 $9.98
Mugungwha The Bear 10 11 $3.30
Mukluk The Husky 11 13 $4.95
Mum The Bear 10 11 $13.90
Mystery The Sea Creature 13 13 $14.64
Mystic The Unicorn Fine Mane 3 2 $39.99
Mystic The Unicorn Fine Mane None 2 $14.15
Mystique The Tiger 12 13 $2.79
Mystique The Tiger 12 13 $3.99

CLICK ON THE LINKS TO VIEW BEANIE BABIES PRICES BEGINNING WITH THAT LETTER

#1-4H Letter I
Letter R
Letter A
Letter J
Letter S
Letter B
Letter K
Letter T
Letter C
Letter L
Letter U
Letter D
Letter M
Letter V
Letter E
Letter N
Letter W
Letter F
Letter O
Letter X
Letter G
Letter P
Letter Y
Letter H
Letter Q
Letter Z




Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Ruby - 26 December, 2016

I have a Mystic with a yarn mane instead of the fur, any difference in value?

Reply
Tyler - 7 October, 2016

Hi i have 2 beanie babies id like to know your opinion on prices i have tiny and stretch just curious because ebay has a variety of prices

Reply
Donna - 24 August, 2016

Have Peanut hang tag style 4062
DOB 1-25-95
1995 tush tag
Pristine-adult owned.
Have a value?
D

Reply
Richard - 23 June, 2016

What about Maple the Canadian Bear

Reply
Anonymous - 9 May, 2016

I have a Mystic the unicorn, idk how to distinguish the difference between the different generations. please email me

Reply
Anonymous - 13 January, 2016

Mr. & Mrs.

Reply
Don - 11 October, 2015

Mac is missing

Reply
Anonymous - 20 August, 2015

midnight is missing~

Reply
Brandy Jenkins - 9 August, 2015

March bear with party hat…any info

Reply
Brandy Jenkins - 9 August, 2015

I have Midnight the panther…any info??

Reply
Cheryl - 8 July, 2015

I just went through my collection of beanies, and all are 5th generation tags, I believe 6th gen tush. I noticed one that is a brown monkey, but the tush tag says his name is Mystic. Was this one mislabeled? Any value?

Reply
Tricia - 12 June, 2015

I have Mystic for sale. Call if interested…..209-321-4886

Reply
April Casto - 19 May, 2015

How much is Maple the Bear worth?/

Reply
Anonymous - 17 May, 2015

Is the mystic with a yarn mane more or less valuable than the fine mane?

Reply
    Anonymous - 21 July, 2015

    I think more cuz I also have that one and I haven’t seen pics

    Reply
Anonymous - 3 May, 2015

What is Sunny worth

Reply
mark - 26 April, 2015

have loads of beanie babies to sell looked on ebay why are some priced high and the same ones price for next to nothing on the next page , lost on how to vaule them to set a price any ideas or any where i can take them to get priced thanks

Reply
Lexi - 31 March, 2015

I have two mystic unicorns, both have iridescent horns, but one has a yarn mane/tail and the other has a furry mane/tail. any info?

Reply
Cassandra - 4 March, 2015

How much is mellow

Reply
linda charles - 1 December, 2014

I have a Millennium Beanie Baby with the 3 errors of misspelling of Millenium on ear tag,and tush tag, and Gosport spelled Gasport on swing tag

Reply
Anonymous - 18 November, 2014

What are the values for the Mr. and Mrs. bears?

Reply
Anonymous - 18 November, 2014

What is the value of Mellow? Thank you!

Reply
Paige - 9 November, 2014

I have a whole tub of all brand new authentic beanie babies with tag protectors bought when I was a baby ranging from early 90’s to the 2000’s. I want to sell them but I don’t know where to start.

Reply
    Love My Beanies - 18 November, 2014

    Hello, the best and most active marketplace for Beanie Babies is eBay.

    Reply
Gina D - 14 October, 2014

I have a Millenium bear with a spelling error on the tush tag….it’s spelled with two “n’s”. Does that increase it’s value/

Reply
    Love My Beanies - 16 October, 2014

    Maybe slightly, but there are a lot of fake ones out there and without knowing the history of the one you have it would be hard to tell the value.

    Reply
karmen - 18 September, 2014

What’s the value on “Morrie”?

Reply
Anonymous - 11 September, 2014

Hi! What about Minksy the Bunny?

Reply
Theresa - 12 August, 2014

Mel style 4162?

Reply
Wenda - 3 August, 2014

I have Millenium and Ty 2K, how much they worth please? Thank you!!!

Reply
    Love My Beanies - 17 August, 2014

    Hello! Millenium and the Ty 2K’s have a value of about $2 or so.

    Reply
Tanya - 1 August, 2014

How do i sell my Beanie Baby’s?

Reply
Leave a Reply: