Beanie Babies Price Guide – Letter M

Beanie Babies price guide for ones that begin with letter M.  Prices are from completed auctions on eBay.

mysticMystic the Unicorn
Hang Tag: 1st Generation – Tush Tag: 1st Generation
Sold For: $299.99
Date Sold: January 1, 2014
Top Beanie Babies Sales – January 2014


M&M’s -$8
Mac -$4
Magenta -$12
Magic -See Guide
Maiden -$15
Majestic -$10
Maju -$10
Malaysia -$5
Manchu -$5
Mandy -$4
Manes -$8
Manny -$10
Maple -$4
Marcel -$5
March -$4
Mardi -$4
Mark Martin -$5
Marsh -$4
Marshall -$3
Marshmallow -$7
Mascotte -$4
Masque -$3
Massachusetts -$5
Mattie -$4
May -$5
McLucky -$10
McWooly -$6
Meekins -$8
Mel -$2
Melbourne -$5
Mellow -$5
Melman -$15
Melton -$5
Merlin -$5
Merriment -$10
Merry Kiss-mas -$5
Merrybelle -$4
Miami -$5
Michelangelo -$6
Mickey -$7
Midas -$10
Midnight -$5
Millennium -$3
Ming -$5
Ming-Ming -$25
Minksy -$4

Minneapolis -$1
Minnesota -$5
Minnesota Lady’s Slipper -$4
Minnie -$6
Mischief -$7
Mississippi -$3
Missy -$7
Mistletoe -$3
Mom -$4
MOM-e -$4
Monarch -$15
Monkey -$4
Monroe -$5
Mooch -$4
Moonlight -$4
Mooosly -$10
Moosletoe -$5
Morrie -$4
Morsel -$8
Mother -$5
Mothering -$5
Motherly -$5
Mr. the Groom-$5
Mr. Bean -$10
MR. BUMP -$10
Mr. Dinosaur -$15
Mr. Krabs -$20
Mr. Snow -$5
Ms. Snow -$8
Muddy -$4
Muff -$10
Muffler -$4
Mugungwha -$4
Mukluk -$5
Mum -$14
Mum -$4
Mumsy -$4
Muno -$5
My Dad -$5
My Melody -$10
My Mom -$5
My Mum -$5
Mystery -$40
Mystic -$15
Mystic – See Guide
Mystique -$3


Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Carrie Stagner - 28 February, 2017

I have a unicorn and it has the tag and date 1993. How do I find out what’s worth if anything.

    Love My Beanies - 20 March, 2017

    Need to know the name and which tags it has.

Allie Taggart - 27 January, 2017

I have a Mellenium bear. But mellennium is mispelled as melenium on the swing tag. Gosport is mispelled as Gasport on the swing tag. Also stam missing from the inside of the tush tag. Is it worth much more?

Ruby - 26 December, 2016

I have a Mystic with a yarn mane instead of the fur, any difference in value?

    Karen - 6 March, 2017

    I have several versions of Mystic, only because I collect unicorns and Mom collected beanies. She used to research values and trade sometimes. I have always been told fine yarn mane and brown horn is most valuable.

Anonymous - 30 October, 2016

Who wrote this article? Do some research before spreading bullshit. The Princess Diana bear is worth a shit ton of money, I have 3 beanies that according to you are wor through nothing more than a measly dollar, when they sell for over a grand on ebay and other sites. When pawn shops buy your items, they look at eBay and see what they are going for. The majority of beanies go for hundreds of dollars. Not a couple dollars. This article is stupid.

    Love My Beanies - 20 March, 2017

    I’ll sell you a bunch for $20 each so you can sell them for $100+++…..

    anonymous - 16 June, 2017

    MOST sellers on ebay are MISINFORMED. They try to fool buyers that arent knowledgeable on the differences and worth so they can steal their money. Dirty people all over ebay, etsy and all other websites for selling worthless beanie babies for extremely high prices. Why do you think all of their listings are all still on there? Their just waiting for an uneducated, wealthy buyer to walk by, THATS IT. The beanie babies that have value are the ones with the black and white tush tag and the one sided ‘ty’ hangtag that does not flip open like a book. Period. That means it is a first generation beanie baby. The 2nd and 3rd generations have the flip open like a book hang tag and red and white tush tags. Tush tags with a heart and ‘ty’ in the middle of the heart have a little bit more value than the 4th generations (and on) with the hang tag and tush tags with the yellow star on it. 2nd and 3rd generation tush tags do not have the beanie babies name on it and 2nd and 3rd generation swing/hang tags have “To: and From:” on the right side and have no poem. Basically beanie babies with the poem and the yellow star on their hang tags are worth no more than $3.00.

Roger D. Peterson - 22 October, 2016

How much is Morrie the eel worth?

RD Peterson

Tyler - 7 October, 2016

Hi i have 2 beanie babies id like to know your opinion on prices i have tiny and stretch just curious because ebay has a variety of prices

Donna - 24 August, 2016

Have Peanut hang tag style 4062
DOB 1-25-95
1995 tush tag
Pristine-adult owned.
Have a value?

Richard - 23 June, 2016

What about Maple the Canadian Bear

Anonymous - 9 May, 2016

I have a Mystic the unicorn, idk how to distinguish the difference between the different generations. please email me

    Anonymous - 28 June, 2017

    If you have a mystic there are three one is tan with yarn hair
    1 the second one is mystic with and metallic horn And yarn hair
    The third is worth more soft hair and a metallic horn The first one is the most rare

Anonymous - 13 January, 2016

Mr. & Mrs.

Don - 11 October, 2015

Mac is missing

Anonymous - 20 August, 2015

midnight is missing~

Brandy Jenkins - 9 August, 2015

March bear with party hat…any info

Brandy Jenkins - 9 August, 2015

I have Midnight the panther…any info??

Cheryl - 8 July, 2015

I just went through my collection of beanies, and all are 5th generation tags, I believe 6th gen tush. I noticed one that is a brown monkey, but the tush tag says his name is Mystic. Was this one mislabeled? Any value?

Tricia - 12 June, 2015

I have Mystic for sale. Call if interested…..209-321-4886

April Casto - 19 May, 2015

How much is Maple the Bear worth?/

Anonymous - 17 May, 2015

Is the mystic with a yarn mane more or less valuable than the fine mane?

    Anonymous - 21 July, 2015

    I think more cuz I also have that one and I haven’t seen pics

Anonymous - 3 May, 2015

What is Sunny worth

mark - 26 April, 2015

have loads of beanie babies to sell looked on ebay why are some priced high and the same ones price for next to nothing on the next page , lost on how to vaule them to set a price any ideas or any where i can take them to get priced thanks

Lexi - 31 March, 2015

I have two mystic unicorns, both have iridescent horns, but one has a yarn mane/tail and the other has a furry mane/tail. any info?

Cassandra - 4 March, 2015

How much is mellow

linda charles - 1 December, 2014

I have a Millennium Beanie Baby with the 3 errors of misspelling of Millenium on ear tag,and tush tag, and Gosport spelled Gasport on swing tag

Anonymous - 18 November, 2014

What are the values for the Mr. and Mrs. bears?

Anonymous - 18 November, 2014

What is the value of Mellow? Thank you!

Paige - 9 November, 2014

I have a whole tub of all brand new authentic beanie babies with tag protectors bought when I was a baby ranging from early 90’s to the 2000’s. I want to sell them but I don’t know where to start.

    Love My Beanies - 18 November, 2014

    Hello, the best and most active marketplace for Beanie Babies is eBay.

Gina D - 14 October, 2014

I have a Millenium bear with a spelling error on the tush tag….it’s spelled with two “n’s”. Does that increase it’s value/

    Love My Beanies - 16 October, 2014

    Maybe slightly, but there are a lot of fake ones out there and without knowing the history of the one you have it would be hard to tell the value.

karmen - 18 September, 2014

What’s the value on “Morrie”?

Anonymous - 11 September, 2014

Hi! What about Minksy the Bunny?

Theresa - 12 August, 2014

Mel style 4162?

Wenda - 3 August, 2014

I have Millenium and Ty 2K, how much they worth please? Thank you!!!

    Love My Beanies - 17 August, 2014

    Hello! Millenium and the Ty 2K’s have a value of about $2 or so.

Tanya - 1 August, 2014

How do i sell my Beanie Baby’s?

Leave a Reply: